Readwise is very good at one job: collecting your highlights from Kindle, articles and books, and bringing them back to you later. It is also a subscription, and some people want their highlights in a library they own, paid for once. This post is about that group, and it is plain about who should not switch.
Muse is our own app, so weigh that. It is not a copy of Readwise. It covers the part of Readwise that holds your highlights, and not the parts that read for you or remind you.
What Does Readwise Cost?
Readwise's pricing page lists four plans. The full plan, with Reader and Highlights together, is $9.99 a month billed yearly. There are cheaper plans for highlights alone or Reader alone, and a Highlights Lite plan that the page says leaves out tags and notes, exports and Reader. There is no free plan: the page says Readwise is free for the first 30 days, and after the trial it costs a monthly fee. It lists no one-time option.
Muse costs $29 once, with a 14-day free trial. The full Readwise plan costs about that much in three months, so the gap shows up from the fourth month onward. That comparison only matters if the full plan is what you would otherwise pay for.
What Does Readwise Do That Muse Does Not?
A fair amount, and it is worth listing before anything else. From the same pricing page:
- It imports highlights from Kindle, Apple, Kobo and more than 40 other sources, and syncs new highlights as you make them.
- Daily Review brings old highlights back by email and in the app, so you rediscover them.
- Reader is a read-it-later app for articles, PDFs, EPUBs, newsletters and RSS, with text-to-speech and an AI assistant.
- It can capture highlights from a physical book by scanning the page.
Muse does none of that. If you rely on Daily Review to resurface what you read, or on Reader as your reading queue, Muse is the wrong replacement.
What Does Muse Do for Your Highlights?
It keeps them on your Mac, in a library you can search and export, with no monthly bill. From version 1.0.55, Muse can hold notes and quotes, and there are three ways to get highlights in.
Kindle. Plug in your Kindle and import its My Clippings.txt file. Each highlight becomes a note, filed under a collection for its book. The Kindle guide has the steps. It is a manual import, not an automatic sync, so you repeat it when you want new highlights in.
Websites. Select words in a browser and press Control-Option-E. Muse saves the quote with the page it came from, for Safari, Chrome, Arc, Dia, Edge, Brave and Vivaldi.
A Readwise export. Drop the CSV file onto Muse and each highlight becomes a note, with its book, author, note, tags and date where the file has them. This is the route for leaving Readwise, covered below.
Once they are in, highlights sit in the same library as your links and screenshots. Search reads their words. Notes appear under Types in the sidebar, and View, then Reader, lists them beside the one you are reading. There is also no spaced repetition and no AI reading assistant. Muse stores and finds things. It does not coach you.
Muse and Readwise Side by Side
| Muse | Readwise | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $29, once | $9.99 a month billed yearly (full plan) |
| Free option | 14-day trial | 30-day trial, no free plan |
| Brings in new Kindle highlights on its own | No, you import the file | Yes |
| Daily Review of old highlights | No | Yes |
| Read-it-later app | No | Yes, on the full plan |
| Library kept on your own Mac | Yes | No, in your Readwise account |
| Highlight on web pages | Yes, one shortcut in any app | Yes, in Reader |
| Take everything out | Yes, Export a Copy | Yes, except on Highlights Lite |
How Do You Move Your Readwise Highlights Into Muse?
Check the export before you cancel anything. Readwise's pricing page lists exports as not included on Highlights Lite, so confirm yours works first.
- Export from Readwise. Readwise's documentation points to the export page of your account for the options, which include a CSV file.
- Install Muse 1.0.55 or later. It runs on Apple Silicon Macs with macOS 14 or later.
- Drop the CSV on the Muse window. Muse looks for a column holding the words (named Quote, Text or Highlight) and asks whether to import the rows as notes. Choose Import Notes. File, then Import Notes From a Spreadsheet, does the same without asking.
- Find them under Notes. Rows with no category column go into your Inbox, ready to file. If the file does have a category column, those categories become collections.
Muse picks up the title, author, source, tags, favourite and date columns when they exist, and a Readwise favourite tag becomes a favourite in Muse. Anything already in Muse is skipped, so a second import does not double up. Nothing is deleted from Readwise by doing this.
What Are the Free Options?
There are real ones. The Kindle's own My Clippings.txt file holds every highlight you made on the e-reader, and any text editor opens it. Obsidian's Web Clipper is free and saves web highlights as Markdown files on your Mac. If your highlights are mostly from Kindle books and you never look at Daily Review, one of these may be all you need. For a wider look at buying once, see the best one-time-purchase Mac apps.
Choose Muse if you want highlights, quotes, links and screenshots in one library on your Mac, and you are happy to import rather than sync. Stay with Readwise if the reminders and the reading queue are the reason you pay for it. And if you only miss Reader, the Pocket alternatives list covers the read-later apps.
Frequently asked
Is Muse a replacement for Readwise?
How much does Readwise cost?
Can I import my Readwise highlights into Muse?
Does Muse sync Kindle highlights automatically?
What happens to my highlights if I stop using Muse?
A library with no subscription
Free for 14 days. Then $29 once, and it is yours.